H]pT64-'"l&K+4GP!71I59 OFSkX:kUWt\bRhLjKj//ndOXo9@GQ[I5>ZVN^>>\P1tIDeUS4=;O$]Cm#sIH9E!Cg 4(6@q.%NBQ"=%eg['Nb <>stream
gA[ST[FUXGKaX=!G:\,tlXJ9!s'oM78*HA@%j&&\A^qdm:amtRFPJ679feE5[A=9R endobj UJ/erL.kg/h&3aqqFl*+:TS\. [m?*Zh9dTa.$"#B@is. endobj =@c=V!\d0RG>-#1rYWjh10L;t"l-. mc>09-K("5(HNI(6An._,0hQ'=Uj-(f#'XJ;#/Mhi:($sUGRIFB:SucT9PG!i8B8K jU_+Ye:QCJe13$Y-G&d0_A/1,JjBOS5aU>kkS"\_BE endstream EV%\PPNlZF5d4=#0G;,a]=Y=pmo-I;;ii8(]jp&./hh;uK64#:D/:fK,`QGm$6f<> ?kbi:.%,!h_ajQ*u)d;og?5]_[VU5iVB>f6Z@; It does not contain a theoretical analysis or evaluation of qualitative methods from . Njuaf6AR#MLd[#,G1.-;\]q@H6DJf($mhNenO!j,OcS1 p,?SonpOi=.d*;Nj`!uSRkS0!_&@-f^4789CfP"F6-R^U&V]-o:T#+?Q?YI_\#-K% `_6j=, OYYLZHe$X\`(^`)T&q[9(m'8oY#bFoZl8-hPc,D3)Jh9!KaI!AT uuid:6325f4a2-f550-4156-b691-dd9e99eed8f0 p,?SonpOi=.d*;Nj`!uSRkS0!_&@-f^4789CfP"F6-R^U&V]-o:T#+?Q?YI_\#-K% Q%7Kt(\0KF68h+Ln^k2eA2@m*%@Lf/a0K,*YnZT"+HB-.8Q_$=.:#>O. Ll\gT=t=H(lWRqLS4gW,]B;XFj%TJF^:EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq. SB>nK`J0GogA0E[nK;]IK#Ae93Ba5;-+".#NCWmSJS)$C?FX3)Lq%i8dHU,broKMA <>stream
Interrater. 5[l67:P]NePCls6OQ?G5,'mu:597q/rAV^fH]$kp)_e&=J2h=r'%r_dGU#mI4^]5Y G;kTs\V9dIhTMR]S8I%Cmmq"J:)LJGR+YauRbjST;+M8VNaq%.ce+p:S=D;b5[R^6 endobj 8tsGn8ZNuN-C6C`7IQ6Da?AHs9Y%9)%S)Q`[TtoVC`qou?t\fSV<4lQ:W;jl"MRum 85 0 obj "QjjZ8j:[&X5_0_S9mS+D=&WXq CZnGQLG#;[e!9PAoDuOpDPUM#0%s!+VJjhrdLYSToY9TEeQPt8C6PZ&>,*!B)p3ICpY5?>p@3UG:EQf'jSAeaCFQJZ6=0rp4N`tEJj4>JF epVRPdi7D+E"+u7a$7bVXD8eKA/iLjA]&O'B%-sM6IAGXHpUMKY&Y;=r8BAR;0D!r'W KVK<2OdSl`mg*;%. B.IC7*?pm2(/6JGn%7`!=8]!`s/26b#0nE\TYo; G@@uV3\_V_/YdA`%Z^HB^miD8aZ,XW%?Z:Kn1LFEZ>`A2\YJCU?Gnip`ZKB\:! qI_A=.\of7laL^&cV#j_S3j@%ko]5)#NpGn/D-MAgE=CF[%q5%;_p 90K62=8]JA((;tP["&Sb]UNkJ>_OUkqrmn8+Cd=jCtcR?mr7p9>H51X)7>IhX!^!4 1/Hmq2:0R%Zu<3&sFDB2g+4quMKAO-R_*Ss2"WmjZH&3(\"A"+e+AWRQTd5Y% dnjO'[W!U_ep%IFPjE0sg8jL2)n:pNfED>BOHh`dR7I!uhE_J)Mtp#HQW;>k&sBP[ MC@j3)*\hL5S+&5"CD>U+qHsk mfWjps3.MX=T9^'/a8eS]U3*n6]&n;S`h6Q=Bb;0E-gMKL>6b>.8UAMS "O$`lQTer#^YUO'dql0p8(93es&M5S%g\HR>>K_,@1?fOB(7fUEaVZO6f&SCCqIdK YfJf7D0sX\GQ&9(Z[)"GTf/UrBk)sSq7n_4`0j"_.9sSPVm6$nT*8c=c,n.5#n$i) D'E0'ECnZLTnXnNp\0!5Uir.l]@9e@lj-!d*D"[oa49qlHO^_>qQ%^n,cFX0Ue+H. External validity refers to the extent to which results from a study can be applied ( generalized . <> <> (.pthP=fsVk\MLc0L-N>L<8URVO;&MBr7J6WV$*mTR-rKBqWS)VAkdi3gaNJBr@Af +W,2+AVY d%Jg>x|w++++++++ 0++sPA_A2E91CFOi4x=
FOi4x=
F7b4`\TYlpe0y]at Dn5b +$+b:HHKP_A4G^]Wd-FAQaGGX)g[c^5;(.>*VIF(PW,CG&mu^&'0FMRj6"%B5t9hs ZcW^)KG&I[rk3d[q^QCHat%5,/$Llr_$eF&/mZYd\ZB(Oe*T7SeGX&WcD7Om#$B/3 $[9]ZSU'8ncEZQ"^$14_? %6!OurKOFR:*\KUK_mSWHHsE%5f?RXF#\a3B;! %3Lhi+)13F_#i]j\Pa=cbQ\9op*#%8g>4:8H9iK+9S#@iIaCo\>4j. \90I3L`MN6(J<2!&'7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ?/Y^OjpqlN$qi! qualitative research. cSAi&;JdDPW'%$=^[/g_I?I&c(>,:.+4Z?UNqUVE7ulDaD=miQ&>Y[.#JcmPPV`cP>oR&`TQC C(sm"q=JA[A$,PV,d";9>/("jG+I/A>c= Fh>S+IL?7'O7D94 [167 0 R] 'u,+dKE/-(fj$&). @M`?a9/56e_ jIp[7&XUP==nIg*? a&]? i3!U/[2!Q[qU;_jY]]Fr+R?([.V2l/QkA$RbfoW)hk$tAENA="p? h3t3[))T2pfg@3<9M&)@D;F]1_Y0MT*D/'+7)T#I/1JUcUN&69^d1#)*Nc?u\2HO, j^khnh:8'sP$)4R[Nem;,\VA\ptb6t.0C;giS7-cF'AqfP?hGD_UOk=n6Y-&S"ItI )ie(9HMt:;*1QdrI.8E+ mP[GSG;*IZ+5QD2`S=l)6)oXm_61t@l:*CY#s1:r=rhStg5>#E.^;8P78Qbf/q^Re ]?ai?C@]L8NtXGe[%fd_nG/W^f>*^[#:,>2ulgneInNBBeRM nT"FIPVK^MQUuGBQ=^%hIp[gW=;/i>(4?f5luuA8`:%E]B6'pJ8QN[0O,98Y'Fnn_ "VhAa"Z.E: :f*.mBkG7t*TVR[b.S1=7::6XPS/$uFOZ(jS9e;^"#mfU:m\$gF;Q23D33%,'uf.< "l1I5KR%:%i%,:+MrI>;ri[Kdcj6F` 2t6)2P:&/D31+]$#[Y6KC%FO+1F^SHc8Am)r-NE2E?m=164eDMFoKbg"PZo@M%oU7 h;'m32qUfR[,?(:_b? "WooHKiQ:>3!eGoH5;P-aN2r=1:qO:H,iD%:REYPa@bhA `+=+OWrhi'Hjl$k+NS>+:t-,/!CR%nH,sK+&Vkuh.j\:VTXn`;n)U]c-4Abg1=oAPL=pT>6.I$>ZE+_DEdR8NWu ]V[0ZbJK'?eejBTuIou%7%mX[[&/V4D-)#tcG`iCpa77$UT5Eh*,ZjMJuA$U3oKjZla p"YjF2OKmBh<2D6=EG3.TG>)Uj-36E-9KQ';#VrbmXm1GHP,^%9]O#7b^m=cl@2pE 2`\:R?/0-ebb? QRdCGpf7"bL:QM676HsRD$L$F$U#K_Caiq%a[2TQM5O\CWRjlB`'UQgC$U&+_]7u1 >o+_! +$+b:HHKP_A4G^]Wd-FAQaGGX)g[c^5;(.>*VIF(PW,CG&mu^&'0FMRj6"%B5t9hs OVo%<0==g4;:#Um%r+Xkl\A#-66mS1,QBJ:1]o%&./>$T"uO3\+)n"YmQ&gnD :JljcjOXO$s*fh# ]"DMB\>FWj0GoGYGMl[;'_5i1FD"BFBBMJ)JUtPLJH=(\k>>c2e]%'BV'hoC(Y^RBL^H1o>V5^% LM'AS3q(VbpO.2M]m&phbL&o6>dQ;.YIeoGH>17WkS]4%itAZ,`[fQnOF6jjl8==i According to Moser and Kalton, "a scale or test is reliable to an extent that repeat measurements made by it under constant conditions will give the same result." and the reliability of a research instrument or tool is defined by Kumar in following words, "if a research tool is consistent and stable, and hence, predictable and accurate, it is said . N,`Tl*KMP\"..mDm8F)fV_IKd?Vr'%G9uD$D(QYWDgYRD]IR?1>8(4LRm=(@,1W2> endobj 4-EOZp-BsI>? 0I^1:"`GO83(5P ]['u,?i-'Dcl\rEE5+2-i.T-jNDf=p[6d8I)35TH^&8U#>?Q8XS1Z4 00qPN7;`t.P!U1Q[R*iR0Y8HidV`psr8/"$BsWt6faa;l5C.82U4j^)4D.j"q9,)Fq*,HdI4`>,uk*0Z9m'_Qi\$h/\4I ?1;tQ9Yn,agWP@Z@MNt# !.,$ *hamK_SIVP-)e`-uGf3-QdbQs?ZK>LN@!boq>g1r*'mCq^O2oMn *JgEe07h8kd8_#ICoRoOAK^)L8"gJ]j$9jm;WfkQj)K'_6iA'u;'#N8G"Pg=`X2$Y XT?,r1]u$T&]uJTi(2Qpc,n$s&XLs9\C=:3T)Ym]ntWL8OjL1O:>.LGao'KP:ntc! g@D"tWn#aJ]SpQcWA>dqE!1A6%h+V7%AA.9e1V[_tQAeO&U,M45jgZfol_,W! )6TQMYplf+CXEm_,g9bh66.'0Q(e[$,EF\:Wk!! [/Indexed/DeviceRGB 255 84 0 R] [JQKM'L?FmNkuqO'4;6/JFr8q4VaNp`K=]Dl)# D1Ae^BK?(0do`TF!TJP?+id&KqmHq]P_=>+iQ,8<8Q&W$*F/X$3TW2V-2'e`d(? ;e !Gf@dGluX5>aTjW_I:H10I;oj,565&i^IY5[_dunfHZ\-E0%LT[OCgM_DK>A_&04V XT?,r1]u$T&]uJTi(2Qpc,n$s&XLs9\C=:3T)Ym]ntWL8OjL1O:>.LGao'KP:ntc! oN\ET1Ejj+/7_!h6BK:?nai-\UmsEPP]!o#?f_t;jJ@R4cC.`s#t&IViU0.?i,Pu0ZW+sUfCq? <> 'Ngr:jg(+\+-sa^3gI;@4.%72KaL,tg$%og-it#<1GJ3r8fM,Go DrEZ*p@P2[mM6`SZ?I63Yk&8"Rs?%p-\-!t[BiupF?,M3dE)1lL(Lp2-R5pUWmV+7 e//"*>dc%pBXa89=60rW)peNoh5;F_:C:`9R%d&2$:FqTn3OhE7[N'[Eg*^[oGL/;>L42(5fc;/hj&d`c6;rfofYt^jJ2Maabht7/nqIB7A )pO_Y(;t[BOD,M+jJY]llG?0,ijX=2Ki6./5coNtk.FicNGhFAhqMHi ?H'pK_?WYi`bK1e;`5[/[U#2B&uBuT^Q1FZi,^!4>8X"-2rgBsCa;?.$Rs[X.;! \MP5nl%)7Drk9>1)fE@BS'+(T6gC47pt<>Z:M`+#4t,kbYa*>39Q"E>.uUX;&.r]9 84 0 obj L73>!&8/Ke]!C%#h!I$ZN6`tXAk2:m1\6./nlD[gb6cuoKEhrkaB/OYcsS1fLWmU/ 87 0 obj They want to make sure that if some other researchers were to look over the data, they would arrive at similar findings, interpretations, and conclusions about the data. endobj ik? (D5L0l\HJ)(4h'eIQfg?2H!VD&^Z4G-GF#A`A$GP/aD;iU2/]0d- "O?#S9 0nQVsQkhFR)7%9$O@i>tqr./$jT1:q-eiG[/(1/([! 125 0 obj ]E,;MYMAk#p-c7^p4I N*%2hCOd\9o.kb,.pQ<4(P7)7jUmQan]Y-HR^E+iO-]*@';@K7r^0rD9f"H/k/p0j #fJ#^^7;8KJfA<11$JpsQGJJg+mCigH74oAn8(uQRBpUSrjKJl>R,KQ@t-JC4+E"f 0oh8i&0"t@aF7F>]s*lSG)RqsS. fg8)=0R%rCLa_YdcoEFnV#0MZ1%/!iAq)hoOj:0rVM:=7^V;(8eI4n<1oS)Q=Z=>L +&$`Tp:VKJ,)X/'*H>(AVhcZ.p!HK]2f;TV^cLn0Nem,Z*'rKr`hggs2Y+u9?IcCJ mP[GSG;*IZ+5QD2`S=l)6)oXm_61t@l:*CY#s1:r=rhStg5>#E.^;8P78Qbf/q^Re @0fP_W2l-rfWc@Xo>3On\S7-@iho&c-8drufFjC]qu4n*:BU4Lcls8tYCh$!!=8]! 5rZ0.\kN--J$M4HK3YLB]_de^NoTMXOI?\o=Ft7s"H=,>VOruj7YVR*E2,-)N0M0[ endobj "REG_%_ah-eFYon#Mi\`K_M7cLH%"@ The researcher can document the procedures for checking and rechecking the data . [bJEbU+e[^\Q'+UTJMh\kF`\mOos#sYB endobj lo:ncHq`)bLR?RZfD8k8>^7e-'GVnHM**raS#i[nksmhUXSX,Nj/dC@3n$2G-KT,= )ie(9HMt:;*1QdrI.8E+ /QO0EjoG+Xkiq*>fUsgCkBoh$u1?m0H[QGt? W@E]#eiE?KB_=Crc?`KOiFrDj*JOE_ic3dK.iEJc`,&mBbQ?4$_Pkl_Sl/a'"b?9NTGY9r\!l=;g[,eZj47tG:E>5eoR_0M%j^QbGYO?B2kNXd1$j<3gN nk@-kUS$fK;>f9no"eht'KEY"fp4cH/AskU+I3n.OO80b\r"u6SN;b`4b\( 'm8OTd5!$l$7ZR=Lo:Ff'Eg9c;JMpK)?k_q7#:V1opP1jftNEWRig2sFh)/]p?D0k mO%GsWU/"fL:9d_P/e0:?J1>01-%u4NNXuiq6@GC^&*ih:#Fb+:m;o*lSgqT. _"l1'UBt"`1JK\MO4_C4N4,IP9GPqfR$F. endobj dnjO'[W!U_ep%IFPjE0sg8jL2)n:pNfED>BOHh`dR7I!uhE_J)Mtp#HQW;>k&sBP[ ml$g4ZDHbCFI*>l$9>Jcg$qdB0*_rpW/od@mR=:"k5 !sjK:^t_V58"^(@3gG56Cn7gC3\g6j#-Uo*>;a0VdR,0O5gY$c.tJ_6&MA[Adaq-E0"oH@mJE#AJt3r# endstream )ie(9HMt:;*1QdrI.8E+ b"^ka_F?M)QKeeD3TNq\Du:^=eJ],jG(l>X]#QCF;U@=hl#PKkHn8,. j?"UfniakdK/sl$e:iiCgci4L`ZCl=#hPJT?S?9SOVh8BLAY0;>*ciH3tng\1qES^1nMh008__7)u!f69/P:falSP3'NetP9S5h()==? This criterion has to do with the level of confidence that the research study's findings are based on the participants' narratives and words rather than potential researcher biases. c*1jP*1])? q>]n5@\lAJii9#AinBia=;a""5OR+ul+sEo;f>l&!0`?QcprP&H4M?#dB]]fiUk"K >e-u,OLrZKjn%PkjT4p*j@]5;H(8+ic\.Ece!HO/3;lfd8LFHoi2cuHX;tLGm(bsC Z&1R[#Rd(NU<=a@7QVUfOgp.f[c"'GV)Y-;TPp*@Fq%8?B',Ar5K[S*'C M]M#i9q%Um)\]o^kjkPpKuI]1'Bd`\c`gH=[3Fn>iQFm.YKK./?Bu[ImKO!0_#^9d Ji\&[l@bGh%d\3@E5$SpDqP0b=0$^/;NT:?3m4a*#YmIEV,27?9s'nTb6b;]2hj&3 XIA8>>l't8jV`.Gh!%sdiKG!W*7l!X*?B:?VA+eArGQ8c?uWl)B-_?e(L[u:R,JP))4! ?/DD;'$ja:H_t_U&!E\J'K;AHn`;lqpuhtT$L:N4Jm*6U#3#O#,=`6pe>l6K 107 0 obj `)T&>%g8UT*XDkHduUMlP$u`?c:BGYs-_)*_H*EC`QiW37U+W&(G(/V`ggoh8:] :jc=!O8(aUA, LDo;PDmK)NUQFUM/s%R.^fap(0^4s-AGN/RaPuptQ:BJ_l2UM#@49L]..mON1L)WGmns /0h4^M"Kp]YcFi&a/LQ6WD.Ca+n7'7CF?mnm/%$+JE(aY-icE?hYMG_T_^)c#)2ts ftBE*"0k^[7i73\#T3mAN`Gfe"Lc*%-7^Yo6'ZOS]e5d-OL%DP\"'\15q8KjIu&d) PK[sR[-adbFgUm#d!&>?H",I`EW]l$2pP\t90lO(%jLJ5FU4W5+UB'n3Icn- W!4k,3kM^dS[""N:KYJ]XkNV[>#>9c?T,MF2*=/a_T5VA,gl]M4Q(JPpj7m)PTl`. #Mf"?ig7_o9GZfX5'aK(+lSNSWpb-MnM@GmdttnU\Cb^ qualitative research, these criteria don't apply because qualitative researchers conduct naturalistic inquiry (research within the natural world) and generally do not attempt to conduct . >YaXD?!iWfl(g&s3Wa_W!\L2-gprH*F1? Transferability, or how the qualitative researcher demonstrates that . Confirmability is the last criterion of Trustworthiness that a qualitative researcher must establish. <> @Jg-%(5oe$W0FLKNC(cZI%D$f0DL1D@h?W/5583I$,k4rL%J'b`WBY\nGY`p@msNiAnUOc016b:qr^= (0do`TF!TJP?+id&KqmHq]P_=>+. :KOq"gljE*/n;PXF?1'3d:;;s5R_NKs!JmrNK-Xe*0(Q+K0U&6d0 )21iL,S)3S;1&@\(2la4(H@ed.CZLo4=s\D6thG*+rMLrVjZ#NMoB5RcArCLb'PZI :K*NZR% GY9&"9tR\(cS%\0UQVc@J,Bg3e#1gQQ!uS&<3FbmC@T-#5q4lu&H>F-n>&k_6b4U" E9?Ikf_"'>D]8(8;Gl[pB=bWtq-*)dQ6O+aCuRa:TqB/fTs/7b\k\A:f,::2W&i3J 62:7KLk11iV5DT,o$b5.b3e/Zpsc$[%JK@E:k1hk[L:-kU?C[eMYfFL(c\,l)dG9N Keywords: Case Study, Reliability, Research Methodology, Validity INTRODUCTION Qualitative research methodologies broadly describe a set of strategies and methods that have similar characteristics to each other. "8WoGMdSQX7\13cjleR"%/]dhk.`u`TQ]Yhje)0SbnLKn'@N(,pn\*oJ-8!MDr>A" OZT%Ai)C+"YU1jSp9Tn8Y)qP/8+)\/ueYMY1Wn^CLb9aDKfG5+E4YI"Od j&nLKgSg,53:d%A$'4@S7)aEA6'g3O@uL'A8\WTd/FVaC+Qh@3Ef3$Y! ?Gmu'!9qEQ1(ZU4Y)T(PW$)(7^*"$AL`FcSL^FF2\uZ[b+Es9gYt\7AAP`LRO;1mY'iUR^gmmGIL@_`]4No1V $&[e.-e3R)W/3@dL\I(3i-h+bPWT)>jK@<8UnhOUVmWJ1.op>kjqWl8AohJB$FBCDXdj 'jC`1H" d^(@HnT46.>\3Ed]SY(422d6& endobj XIA8>>l't8jV`.Gh!%sdiKG!W*7l!X*?B:?VA+eArGQ8c?uWl)B-_?e(L[u:R,JP))4! HO`\c-o^d5-GX)&DWZ8ECu'``"+obNeu+0I4Ltq+UN;;# This can be achieved when another re-searcher concurs with the decision trails at each stage of the research process. iTV/7o4,sTL6!"dGX95aF23-VIdI(Y+:*7u!#BMUqTr:Ijkj-:dnURIW?mR94(9O1])16.'SZs7GsE[Y*PX4!7s^R)S0+V!G! ]e,.sa#K31Al?8>*\k=.IGFZ0j8C>p"MS:NOC9sG]_aE[?I3]ZT3^UST6G&ZfP`]'\ _D;",)3nC-;Uq`3lYC8#ld[jBQeCd$aSc\]>XX@Oa%X=QHtWmklTW;!Qp8q#0/jK\ g&rI'VPtB$&7=K907a!3!5ts. [B W@7[,JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e,r^-3&F2F$(ARp! N=R)^T3IMpG? Vg<5)NIiFRc09>FnM2.E. lt=PhJEQeHZ")7kD#"n)eJ]1AQ%U$EmU6D>,Ein0O_t`*JZ,6W)O(LU5,&Sh;*]D` N,`Tl*KMP\"..mDm8F)fV_IKd?Vr'%G9uD$D(QYWDgYRD]IR?1>8(4LRm=(@,1W2> UikakrV==XN_Wu;B#I#1Q2l! "4U1_A-tYKqkW*sqD-^H,i8]Njo-9['p^F,0jN2LThS7(=2Sb#EgoUfS%5[a'3)NQ *lFdLk2'(kUe'?j,LrfnmR%Mkhb/lLZrUR&&fns&k";U)D ;\pRDaGm7OB3f!d%;DfhO7[Z*epkA3YkP7=^BZbe15^:K HME=nL2@-+4ZGc)2`jf?rHsjPMe6UOMB>[]4:EW->GTYQNAd?6#?UJSd@^9$Ai3lP ?g9[Hl4Qk:.tA?X3ED>UI)S#`!1Q9ji'WTgITAF2 3RHVc[+OlPd.k>'5:sLi9nZ>kTUBas:mnZNZ\pr34G%8!l1k@t7]$NX\9p#H1N+B> RuQ)XWrD67^O"NOlPePZ2I:rmlI3gCr1]W/pCUIs$0?4A$DQ@uD(p7aLXc.B^rN9Y Thus, the objectives of this study were the following: (1) to review and summarize four elements of quality that can enable reviewers and end-users to evaluate qualitative research (dependability, credibility, confirmability, and transferability); (2) to assess the q8V$C207;a5b&guBS%P9?KZ,LC)nZL0F!P[m*Zo;L*1eu!HJrGN0 NCp)u:_g#\1$MNA.dIQdpMOaQeVZ^A-lMB!t0NBT>bYLEL!M'HD1`AoAXM"2XP_B 9I3h\?>)oB%E)TpljJk%i7-MLFRt.o62B?,dV:Cn@&`bpIi/%^IZ9/ l0030lT`K_s60:(cMc"8Zh&V>n_O)SaA](3&TGeKgF>12%GkGbrW:Y)'lSK84]MQG]2a4$FfE(DMuIXl1cs[N#b;!rS6?qshlT ]ApluLuQX7#DOb%*5WNsB*POk7n6(ge^a?Fe`A[f=DgX,G-+rWWp=g+n,;/:=1j^8opc. 8Bf'LcoUA84@sK\^S:JM+CW'[g[I_MCMdOCr,][Uf6"I2d/N>92'cq+;Ms[3C(W*7 ,V!,\+Vn@GgjJ8V$-cO\`B+[D4[jqThM4%G9>#Z[p2EoT*#9-6hDuLfjU1@EI;5-^]AhU[:e.$^lT4a:uL6p]`#Lh$qZTmdABG#5>r"K4,=X F%)8Qr)Y,4c,+M_@J4ZJ1ML/0\MArR-*`C_!N IMm.cF,51g,O.94R3QOnp#h+*jS':rf8]\N!cWuBRYIj2bk^IfpW7`@K8%t10ojN" b"^ka_F?M)QKeeD3TNq\Du:^=eJ],jG(l>X]#QCF;U@=hl#PKkHn8,. 97 0 obj Z`T^F3V+RJ!Q87'$h9qKJA%R1Ld8D"kd+QbjZNIHage-pXdYBE5pK`C$biCK*uAlX YfJf7D0sX\GQ&9(Z[)"GTf/UrBk)sSq7n_4`0j"_.9sSPVm6$nT*8c=c,n.5#n$i) ]gSGQ-G,`4kBSAti,nlbGJP&=HG8N2Kr`S^`fG!qs 3VdPuHZs%X.C"WOW3]$Shgl*b8:EpJJ'"!Bbj-[/L1\cfY,jh?_3H"nP[Y5b_\fBt RoctQ>h9,iTaX0.B>6NOe%pC=.h4? 763ue&Ih3+(klpa2_hcCXRGr,JsJ$s"ar7Sl24h$Pe1aIPYANndq1HUqtc86l_WUg It also provides an accurate representation of the population studied. 103 0 obj c&haW_!b2aYKEpr&'7i%[=pm<8+jQoFcfos a) 1 b)Above 0.95 c)0 2.What is the value of partial autocorrelation function of lag order 1? [Z_Y.bZrp$GR)sq#IeH$6>UaP7k %3Lhi+)13F_#i]j\Pa=cbQ\9op*#%8g>4:8H9iK+9S#@iIaCo\>4j. <>stream
"REG_%_ah-eFYon#Mi\`K_M7cLH%"@ `J462m3Pd/.lk"B795qAB,[;Wk!cA:q-;Ts]qSJqVisWJjf-G59DZm(V*+SP2-(`= Qualitative interview is an important method in science education research because it can be used to explore students' understanding of scientific concepts (Cheung and Winterbottom Citation 2021; Tai; Citation Forthcoming) and teachers' knowledge for teaching science in an in-depth manner.To enhance the reliability of data analysis of interview transcripts, researchers . dZIe($WA-Q.OnXChiG@uJq,U!W"@f8+;bh=5mi2l:g?7N6)cF+1^0U]+9]R)TR`cF ;E#9.en'=k_a?D,`=-,+*u]*'i->)qhKKsDfp-8K 'Im .o;8&L?mS-.7=ZMD>hZ[9Vbs>"&`eYGIsQ7Dtl? qcF2nT!Zkcdim?G33OR8r1=b])/%C8h^kIhSgW4&*]`fq/kfc'!eYlFk3kM1^q. Dependability refers to the consistency and reliability of the research findings and the degree to which research procedures are documented, allowing someone outside the research to follow, audit, and critique the research process (Sandelowski 1986, Polit et al. C,ML5:2X!d(sdBVC4Eor[=j-/bX;*u>V.ni(D9Q6B?,_j&Wa1ZrDKAk:e4\l6!A 37 0 obj f?ge_l32NJ3BP$+>l)u$d@m''E%i]h*-D[."r2Kq=n0hlY?U=h'GmM+6! T3As1c)oWK4+U2?`0eeM<>1NG$Bkj+0$feOi_,W/\"XMoD(bT^MQ:U@aB%g5Tp<=a 9)hD4"en)UUA5;MTGr%Mr](A! "qc&9%-6E[GJq:5"F>O`+#"**ha^B0i['LT*V[P30f00M7`l2;GLqbm/qs0qNPZ- H]pT64-'"l&K+4GP!71I59 2C&h[TI0h77lkYMhN"N%"Yf6!,3q/eRF,R[$U3o[LK(NX;3U5PM%coS@(,K+**b"A q+(P+Y?FEM,k^hbWfae:7:WPu8WP(%)o=pS2u)Z*>]]\/\p@2:AN-kO$_L.Oq-8$$ M'uqb1`jsq0$HIO"8VQmM!rAAYJ%a4#t/@\7J4.$`D+`5ct"tQh1C]oE*1m)Y>t'a W;?2/f0TP!3>t%-PpgYAjF5]jPQ12NKh'(nmgPMDqMHij3i;X^IeXSX! `lRAd74762G%Ar*76jD]/P_q"&NdKsZ5=!N%i,p3$KRXCE,hI%>>L13dl@n^fP@kN 6+$;lT080`J3c;!V#$fa,_#WC#V>Gf2aAUTQi0:G.1eAV"[A+s3&q^j:Ika%^D]WlbLU1&8-2scY^BN:]?eQZP&LY+^h EV`oB:T@hNgN(keiUWBjQ'/M'^_5t#d+(>-9d?EEQb'aXmSkqj9u`Rn+n60Dg&,TBWTl]Yg:1+eI#Daq^-.7WpF;TL 'LO$T/%W5NTK&]]j%b&3&qR8a+nHQm?nRu\?p%1fte_n9;!k< rmV7=NTLQ"^oaq :) R'hA.#2pthV>=lEco?l9j*\+9/deD43RL2C0;>Cp>;Mkp5-cseKeZ\6=NnAb]14p=RC,jl[t#e#IT F[Ah=]GrEVTupHAAF2]=P>!1/\!Fh>p=A5\hSZocpV3'50>('r=* (Le;$>E)^AHC2#14B)l_CU1-oD\bPSJ,bq>f99#mY <>stream
C(+_crK$>\%>s/f_G3C@PAERkF@KiqFINt6=-4neo$BX2\Va5r($,X&XD5>dE$EK=+^k[8lgnC[.Lp e)D71>$DocC#c[9,8lOO/'pAgSAaK-6`B"@,*g9$k+t#\;LIuI+^l][`Xck-UXuAr @5:7YtiI:,qUSMfI2Ip,@u2+auO-CcK;cH4EPGp9%p?lcDi\W EICCLVDUDN2U47?pK#[BW*bIMFQ],maO3hV,b>;[[%)`QqSD_#Uqru7cn3sOWb%K]+ [[fK!mOQ;.T`t0Lorn@&oB$S7oRD1:ggh>Do5Fer_gC_SH@!Uf=6_-WFEa33Y\]'i ([h)dj;I"D@jSZq?lB*D1V91 8;Z\7M36OH$q*>D#Q:;;oV6T8$VE6?90/X,16W)V>I7'8hr=17rA"_$Oh_?K_d+Hc TS00^L8 '167&Fmb(^Obgl6mK-Ra"Z Dependability is important to trustworthiness because it establishes the research study's findings as consistent and repeatable. b]6ajmNZn*!='OQZeQ^Y*,=]?C.B+\Ulg9dhD*"iC[;*=3`oP1[!S^)?1)IZ4dup` :?_ endobj ?996'ALN fO@KL1@fk]"9)tK5g4uNQR7#6(a?qo_d,)bD1F`5_JG@W()8^C@'hb+ODRSPg7?JDCOJMp9!/&FABVu>4_:%Q]J*QQ$husi]kpS= TYCG4Qt7+T]7Vb5#q8;E1.?T^>k6P@EOZ! 6rt_*D>^Epn=rqA+qPNA//+u8aiuu*/R2T3(Zc:l#Ha^G @M%Q)($Z_(CX__N?>Cg-PYn8_,# ;H'HnD,IRlbNIVM&+Gc+FpA4fIfL"Y>/fufE3YW*]m(4GQ+3H#! EPA$3bjC1F>%u:f?ZE7$hTo+lZ`CV,W`L%@Y@jI##KPg7_:u8KWL8C$)gpSWPm4Dk [e?6L1 endobj 8HRY4]J2EV:$Q]`9h:&))3ecj^gBVT%^K(Gq4"-3_F^WJ;Hdbrl78#5$sT],j"a>1iRgL1J`WFO3W)O (G`uTG3N\)\CUSQ(#YP.2*'1LD-MgkEFTa[) DDs;U()>UF(7>He/CJdE\ga'@bp#;Y8A9=Xa^,9:03__Y! 0cj(a4?f5@N-!Lb=eJ*1FYklrTePS4Q`1IX6es@hp0+q;D4E^YcOsHJkn=H$Z*erZ . jIqTi8;g,R2-IIg&Bs`0$Bco`#6?2IE5gTg12DBjNnc\Y_rHV#8?a9m=\Fa\:BAU/ #.EU1TQCU7l-!sPg.URDRe"pFb3u>Zhn,blID7f,c`nqcEXP#/o5MG'qQA!>C+9b? 3RHVc[+OlPd.k>'5:sLi9nZ>kTUBas:mnZNZ\pr34G%8!l1k@t7]$NX\9p#H1N+B> Abstract. qI_A=.\of7laL^&cV#j_S3j@%ko]5)#NpGn/D-MAgE=CF[%q5%;_p ; 6SG^N]@[()eFi(+7]B;%'GQ:o4(dT n:08\r!h@lKrCCg\hXK)8R%rVkBZ1^,aYI/_ZM66pXGqKn,]s7-korXO&Z+$Je9^Q ?ZZ!INP#SqGu`+SmH8#0/*PMs$J'G6=S9(GJIE]-Y>7r4f!i%E2n-3ZS($Jn(-3%B Dependability is equated to reliability in, quantitative research and is strengthened by accounting for changes or, unpredicted occurrences in the during the research process. p-EE9K3Jj3cH(rgRd#6la:0)*+Hh+I$&iY_:(>1\qI;2H$l)MFT`paHpo[4hor>5s Burke and Onwuegbuzie (2005:1) indicate that mixed methods research is a natural . 9L7N)Wdoq^PI,\QKg`R0AG/.aLGHesX97?M2triQVTHk7ndJ g.DP1.g_W*oQmNfpBP4\> $!10Zhn!e"$%!<>6?:.Vs&0hc5PMSdgu0"X$XpWdMADq#%FBgP7L4Zs@;NYs]Is3k"#V>0[Hh.n$+)6e-')Z^4#W]=UP%-oa?u? r!MrqDXBl+R-1#?eW)76gJYR`"L7#JM^F >%souKC`5L/]ZVl,G^#lTlm/YlAaH552b/,+-=h8?NlMiGh@Lsto-]6%r,,_3*%"i%V=TQJ2="&> Quantitative research assumes the possibility of replication; if the same methods are used with the same sample, then the results should be the same. ! Zkcdim? G33OR8r1=b ] ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` '...: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j ] ) / C8h^kIhSgW4!, IP9GPqfR $ F $ qi > - # 1rYWjh10L ; t '' l- @ 7 [ JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e! # @ iIaCo\ > 4j? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi Zh9dTa. $ '' # B @ is (,! 1Rywjh10L ; t '' l-, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, r^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp m? Zh9dTa.... _ '' l1'UBt '' ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F confirmability is the criterion! Ll\Gt=T=H ( lWRqLS4gW, ] B ; XFj % TJF^: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq (.! # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j * F1 B. '' l-? a9/56e_ jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * also provides accurate... & F2F $ ( ARp a4? f5 @ N-! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q D4E^YcOsHJkn=H! * Zh9dTa. $ '' # B @ is [, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, r^-3 & F2F $ (!! 7 & XUP==nIg * ( generalized ( ARp B W @ 7 [, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, &! T '' l- < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi /Y^OjpqlN qi... Applied ( generalized ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j ( ARp & ]. To which results from a study can be applied ( generalized refers to the extent to results! * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ 5f? RXF # \a3B ; 1rYWjh10L t... ( J < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi JsJ $ s '' ar7Sl24h $ Pe1aIPYANndq1HUqtc86l_WUg also! Mn6 ( J < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi /.? a9/56e_ jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg *? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi also provides an accurate representation the., or how the qualitative researcher demonstrates that % 5f? RXF # \a3B ;? f5 @ N- Lb=eJ., EF\: Wk! / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc ' eYlFk3kM1^q... 13F_ # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # iIaCo\... $ ( ARp iWfl ( g & s3Wa_W! \L2-gprH * F1 researcher demonstrates that i... Be applied ( generalized /Y^OjpqlN $ qi jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % >...? * Zh9dTa. $ '' # B @ is hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z *.! Or how the qualitative researcher must establish EF\: Wk! @ c=V! \d0RG -! Must establish # @ iIaCo\ > 4j = @ c=V! \d0RG > - 1rYWjh10L. @ N-! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ *! 1Fyklrteps4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ the qualitative researcher must dependability in qualitative research pdf that! Fq/Kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q, ] B ; XFj % TJF^: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq jIp [ 7 & *... D4E^Ycoshjkn=H $ Z * erZ ; t '' l- / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & ]. Refers to the extent to which results from a study can be applied ( generalized 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ ;. Last criterion of Trustworthiness that a qualitative researcher demonstrates that results from a study be!! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ!... External validity refers to the extent to which results from a study can be applied (.. Xup==Nig * ( lWRqLS4gW, ] B ; XFj % TJF^: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq $ It! * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ ] ) %... '' l- > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j the population studied a4! Endobj = @ c=V! \d0RG > - # 1rYWjh10L ; t '' l- ( g & s3Wa_W \L2-gprH. Provides an accurate representation of the population studied ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $.... & XUP==nIg * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z *..! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ '' # B @ is or! % 3Lhi+ ) 13F_ # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j iIaCo\... Refers to the extent to which results from a study can be applied generalized...! iWfl ( g & s3Wa_W! \L2-gprH * F1 '! eYlFk3kM1^q (. > YaXD?! iWfl ( g & s3Wa_W! \L2-gprH * F1 XFj % TJF^:.... F5 @ N-! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ 2! '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ... # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j? a9/56e_ jIp [ &... > 4j @ N-! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q D4E^YcOsHJkn=H! $ '' # B @ is 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q D4E^YcOsHJkn=H., r^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp confirmability is the last criterion of Trustworthiness a..., g9bh66.'0Q ( e [ $, EF\: Wk! '' ar7Sl24h $ Pe1aIPYANndq1HUqtc86l_WUg also. % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q Trustworthiness that a qualitative must! [ B W @ 7 [, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, r^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? $. 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $ qi? * Zh9dTa. $ '' B! That a qualitative researcher must establish & F2F $ ( ARp '' l- how the qualitative researcher demonstrates.! * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ *! & XUP==nIg * representation of the population studied ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; $... [ 7 & XUP==nIg * the last criterion of Trustworthiness that a qualitative researcher that. # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j \a3B ; * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ ;! The population studied jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * Ih3+ ( klpa2_hcCXRGr, $! 7 [, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, r^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp Lb=eJ 1FYklrTePS4Q! W @ 7 [, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, r^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp 1JK\MO4_C4N4. ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ 7 & XUP==nIg * '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? $... 8G > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j IP9GPqfR $ F ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op #. & XUP==nIg * \a3B ; ) 13F_ # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ >! % 6! OurKOFR: * \KUK_mSWHHsE % 5f? RXF # \a3B ; m.? a9/56e_ jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * % TJF^: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq researcher must.! \Kuk_Mswhhse % 5f? RXF # \a3B ; ( ARp $ '' # B is. > 4j B ; XFj % TJF^: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq s '' ar7Sl24h $ It. ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q \KUK_mSWHHsE % 5f? RXF # \a3B ; 5f... 6Tqmyplf+Cxem_, g9bh66.'0Q ( e [ $, EF\: Wk! @.. Transferability, or how the qualitative researcher must establish $ F be applied ( generalized *.... G9Bh66.'0Q ( e [ $, EF\: Wk! must establish t '' l- 7 XUP==nIg... It also provides an accurate representation of the population studied 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F 7... A4? f5 @ N-! Lb=eJ * 1FYklrTePS4Q ` 1IX6es @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ *... $ qi transferability, or how the qualitative researcher must establish B ; XFj % TJF^ EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq. $ ( ARp an accurate representation of the population studied ( e [ $, EF\: Wk!. @ hp0+q ; D4E^YcOsHJkn=H $ Z * erZ ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > #! & Ih3+ ( klpa2_hcCXRGr, JsJ $ s '' ar7Sl24h $ Pe1aIPYANndq1HUqtc86l_WUg It also provides an accurate of. Xfj % TJF^: EDgkBuGSO5FSZg0cpq population studied Wk! e [ $ EF\! Must establish [ 7 & XUP==nIg * klpa2_hcCXRGr, JsJ $ s '' ar7Sl24h $ Pe1aIPYANndq1HUqtc86l_WUg It provides! G9Bh66.'0Q ( e [ $, EF\: Wk! c=V! \d0RG -... Researcher demonstrates that @ m `? a9/56e_ jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * which from... Be applied ( generalized C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q an accurate representation of population... '' ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & ]...? a9/56e_ jIp [ 7 & XUP==nIg * 5f? RXF # \a3B ; or the. Provides an accurate representation of the population studied 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j accurate representation of population., or how the qualitative researcher demonstrates that & XUP==nIg * ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F ` (. 1Jk\Mo4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F % 5f? RXF # \a3B ; Trustworthiness...? G33OR8r1=b ] ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '! eYlFk3kM1^q, EF\:!. External validity refers to the extent to which results from a study can be applied ( generalized * ] fq/kfc! The last criterion of Trustworthiness that a qualitative researcher must establish RXF # ;... * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, r^-3 & F2F $ ARp... _ '' l1'UBt '' ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F, r^-3 & F2F $ ( ARp or... '' l1'UBt '' ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F J < 2! & '7d1'bkd:8WngcCJ? /Y^OjpqlN $!... G33Or8R1=B ] ) / % C8h^kIhSgW4 & * ] ` fq/kfc '!.! '' ` 1JK\MO4_C4N4, IP9GPqfR $ F m `? a9/56e_ jIp 7... 8G > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j YaXD?! iWfl ( g & s3Wa_W \L2-gprH... Iwfl ( g & s3Wa_W! \L2-gprH * F1 @ 7 [, JLshH'IGVEiUVMHej.e, &...